Chapter 11 - Nathan Had a Third WomanJessica Reed was thirty-four.
Single.
A commercial real-estate broker.
Claire discovered that in under ten minutes.
The photographs on Nathan’s second phone showed restaurants.
Hotel rooms.
A beach trip Claire remembered Nathan describing as a “contractor retreat.”
Jessica had been involved for at least fourteen months.
Three months before Nathan restarted the affair with Diane.
Claire almost admired the efficiency.
One wife.
One mother-in-law.
One girlfriend.
Three women receiving different stories.
Diane sat in her car crying.
“He told me he loved me.”
Claire looked at her.
The sentence should have created sympathy.
It didn’t.
“He told me that every morning.”
Diane covered her face.
Claire took the phone.
“You don’t get to turn this into something we survived together.”
“I know.”
“No, you don’t.”
Claire’s voice hardened.
“You are not another woman Nathan cheated on me with.”
Diane flinched.
“You are my mother.”
“I know.”
“You stood beside me when I married him.”
“Yes.”
“You held Sophie in the hospital.”
Diane sobbed.
“You ate Thanksgiving dinner at my table and then started sleeping with my husband.”
“I’m sorry.”
“You knew exactly who I was every single day.”
Diane had no answer.
Claire walked away.
She copied the phone with Maya’s help.
The messages contained more than affairs.
Nathan discussing moving assets.
Nathan asking Jessica how quickly a condominium could be sold after title transfer.
Nathan asking whether a spouse could claim property owned through an LLC.
Nathan discussing loans from “family sources.”
Jessica sometimes questioned him.
But she appeared unaware the money belonged to Claire’s trust.
One exchange mattered.
Jessica: Does your wife know about Naperville?
Nathan: Eventually.
Jessica: And Diane?
Nathan: She thinks it’s ours.
Jessica: That’s cruel.
Nathan: She’ll survive.
Claire stared at those words.
For all Diane had done, Nathan had treated her exactly the way Diane had treated Claire.
Useful until inconvenient.
Another message:
Jessica: You still haven’t told me why your mother-in-law gives you so much money.
Nathan:
She has reasons.
Jessica:
Are you sleeping with her?
Nathan did not respond for sixteen minutes.
Then:
Jesus, no.
Claire almost laughed.
Nathan lied even when no immediate benefit existed.
Perhaps lying had become instinct.
Maya advised Claire to change banking passwords.
Freeze joint credit.
Document marital assets.
Avoid confrontation.
Peter began proceedings to remove Diane as trustee.
Diane did not fight.
That surprised Claire.
She signed temporary suspension papers the same day.
Maybe guilt.
Maybe fear of criminal exposure.
Probably both.
Nathan called repeatedly.
Claire blocked him.
Then he sent an email.
You’re destroying our family because you’re listening to Diane.
Claire stared at it.
Nathan still believed he could frame the story as two women competing for truth.
She forwarded it to Maya.
No reply.
At school pickup, Sophie climbed into Claire’s car.
“Is Daddy coming home?”
Claire’s chest tightened.
“Not tonight.”
“Is Grandma?”
“No.”
Sophie looked out the window.
“Are they still in trouble?”
Claire took a breath.
“Adults made some choices that hurt people.”
“Did Grandma kiss Daddy because she loves him?”
Claire’s hands tightened around the steering wheel.
She chose each word carefully.
“That is something Grandma and Daddy have to explain for themselves when you are older.”
Sophie frowned.
“Daddy said grown-ups can love more than one person.”
Claire’s pulse changed.
“When did he say that?”
“At the apartment.”
Claire looked in the mirror.
“What else did he say?”
“That Mommy wouldn’t understand.”
Claire closed her eyes briefly.
“Did he ask you to keep secrets?”
Sophie nodded.
“He said surprises are secrets.”
Claire pulled into a parking lot and stopped.
She turned around.
“Sweetheart, I need you to know something.”
Sophie watched her.
“A surprise has an ending.”
“What?”
“If Daddy says we’re getting Mommy a birthday cake, you keep it secret until Mommy’s birthday. Then everybody knows.”
Sophie nodded.
“A secret that a grown-up tells you to keep forever from Mommy because Mommy would be upset is different.”
“Oh.”
“You can always tell me those.”
“Will Daddy be mad?”
“No adult should be mad at you for telling me something that makes you uncomfortable.”
Sophie considered.
Then quietly said:
“Daddy and Grandma fought at the apartment.”
Claire’s heart accelerated.
“About what?”
“Grandma was crying.”
“Did you hear why?”
Sophie nodded.
“She said, ‘You promised she would be gone by Christmas.’”
Claire froze.
She.
Claire.
Christmas was four months away.
“What did Daddy say?”
Sophie thought.
“He said, ‘Not yet.’”
Claire swallowed.
“Anything else?”
“Grandma said, ‘I sold the cabin for you.’”
Claire’s eyes filled.
Sophie looked worried.
“Did I do bad?”
“No.”
Claire reached back and took her hand.
“You did nothing bad.”
That night Claire told Maya.
The attorney asked:
“Do you think ‘gone by Christmas’ means divorce?”
“Probably.”
“Probably?”
Claire thought of Nathan’s second phone.
Assets moved first.
Divorce later.
“Yes.”
But something bothered her.
Why had Diane expected Claire to be “gone” by Christmas?
Had Nathan promised simply to leave?
Or had he planned something more aggressive legally?
Claire searched the phone again.
One folder was encrypted.
Maya’s forensic consultant opened it the next morning.
Inside were draft documents.
Divorce papers.
A proposed custody schedule.
Financial disclosures containing false account balances.
And a psychiatric evaluation request.
Claire stared.
“What is that?”
Maya read.
Nathan had prepared to allege Claire was emotionally unstable and incapable of managing substantial inherited assets.
Claire laughed.
“Of course.”
Different story.
Same strategy.
If Claire discovered the money movement, Nathan would say she was unstable.
If she fought custody, he would use Diane as a witness.
Then Claire noticed a name.
Proposed supporting witness:
Diane Lawson.
Claire stared.
Her mother had not only been sleeping with Nathan.
May you like
She had agreed to help him portray Claire as an unstable mother.
And suddenly Diane’s betrayal became larger than sex.
Related Stories
