Chapter 15 - Arthur Refused to Confront Martin Until the Evidence Was Publicly PreservedArthur wanted Martin in a room.
He wanted to ask him whether seventeen years beside the Hawthorne family had meant anything.
Lydia advised against it.
"Why?"
"Because he is a lawyer under investigation."
"He worked for me."
"Not anymore."
"I deserve an answer."
"Later."
Arthur hated later.
But he listened.
Instead, independent forensic accountants preserved every relevant Hawthorne legal record.
Emails.
Document versions.
Access logs.
Vendor payments.
Trust files.
Signature image requests.
No one person controlled the evidence.
Copies went to outside counsel, auditors, trustees, and when appropriate, investigators.
Martin could no longer make one file disappear.
That was the opposite of how Arthur had run family matters for forty years.
He always believed one trusted person should control sensitive information.
Now he saw the flaw.
One trusted person becomes dangerous when trust is the only security.
The audit found $11.4 million in North Coast-related fees and affiliated payments over five years.
Not all necessarily improper.
At least $4.7 million appeared inadequately disclosed or conflicted.
Priscilla's Bellmere received more than $1.2 million.
Martin received substantially more.
Harbor Ridge had never managed an outside family's trust.
It existed primarily to take over Hawthorne functions.
Arthur stared at the report.
"They built a company for me to hire."
"Yes," Lydia said.
"Using fees my company already paid."
"Partly."
"Then tried to make it permanent."
"Yes."
Nolan's trust was not the only target.
It was the doorway.
Because Arthur would sign anything presented as protecting his grandson after Wesley's death.
Martin understood that.
Priscilla understood it.
Arthur felt sick.
They weaponized his grief.
Just as Priscilla weaponized Nolan's.
The family court proceeding moved faster regarding immediate safety than the financial litigation.
A temporary guardianship arrangement placed Nolan with Arthur, subject to professional oversight and review.
Priscilla received limited supervised contact rights pending further findings.
Nolan didn't want to see her.
His therapist advised not forcing immediate contact.
Dr. Helen Abbott also provided a sworn statement confirming the notes Priscilla used were fabricated.
Priscilla claimed Martin gave them to her.
Martin claimed Priscilla created them.
The alliance began breaking.
Arthur expected satisfaction.
Instead, he felt tired.
"They're turning on each other."
Lydia nodded.
"Common."
"Do you think she knew the notes were fake?"
"Evidence shows she forwarded them to Martin before they were finalized."
Arthur looked up.
"So yes."
"Likely yes."
Arthur smiled faintly.
"You're improving."
Lydia ignored him.
Then a forensic email recovered from Martin's deleted files gave the clearest proof.
Priscilla to Martin:
Abbott will never say Nolan lies. We need language that shows his stories are grief behavior.
Martin replied:
I can prepare a summary for internal use. Do not present it as her actual note.
Priscilla:
It needs to look official or Arthur won't believe it.
Arthur stared.
Martin had actually warned her not to present it as genuine.
Then he still helped create it.
Shared guilt.
Different roles.
Another email:
Arthur's file needs at least six examples before capacity becomes credible.
Priscilla:
I can give you more.
There.
Capacity plan too.
Arthur put the documents down.
"I want her prosecuted."
Lydia looked at him.
"That isn't your decision."
"I know."
"Good."
"I'm allowed to want it."
"Yes."
Nolan later asked why Arthur kept going to lawyers.
"Because grown-ups made a mess."
"Like juice?"
Arthur smiled.
"Worse."
"Can you clean it?"
"Some."
"All?"
"No."
Nolan seemed disappointed.
Arthur sat beside him.
"Some things don't go back exactly."
"Like Dad?"
Arthur's chest tightened.
"Yes."
Nolan stared at the floor.
"Did Priscilla love Dad?"
Arthur thought.
"I think she did."
"Then why did she lie?"
"Love doesn't automatically make people honest."
Nolan looked angry.
"That's stupid."
"Yes."
"Did Dad love her?"
"Yes."
"So he was wrong."
"About some things."
Nolan frowned.
Arthur continued.
"Being wrong about someone doesn't make everything you felt fake."
Nolan thought about that.
Then:
"Do I have to stop loving her?"
Arthur's heart broke.
"No."
Nolan looked surprised.
"You can be angry. Scared. Love her. Not want to see her. All at the same time."
"That's too many."
"I agree."
Nolan leaned against him.
After a moment:
"I don't want her to lose everything."
Arthur looked down.
"Why?"
"Because then she'll say it's my fault."
There.
The burden.
Arthur turned fully toward him.
"What happens to Priscilla because of her choices is not caused by you telling the truth."
Nolan's eyes filled.
"Even the video?"
"You didn't make the video."
"Bernice did."
"Yes."
"Will she get in trouble?"
"No."
"Promise?"
Arthur smiled.
"That one I can promise."
The next day, Bernice received a letter from Priscilla's lawyer accusing her of invasion of privacy and improper recording.
Bernice panicked.
Arthur called Lydia.
Lydia reviewed applicable law and context, coordinated counsel, and told Bernice not to respond personally.
No dramatic intimidation worked.
The letter became another document in the file.
Then Martin made his move.
Through his attorney, he offered cooperation.
Against Priscilla.
Arthur stared at Lydia.
"He'll give her up."
"If prosecutors or civil investigators find his information valuable."
"Will it help him?"
"Possibly."
Arthur hated that.
Then Lydia added:
"But he claims Priscilla has one thing we haven't found."
"What?"
"The original signed version of an agreement Wesley never told you about."
Arthur felt cold.
"What agreement?"
"Martin calls it the Separation Memorandum."
"Wesley and Priscilla were separating?"
"According to him."
Arthur stared.
May you like
If true, it changed everything about the final months of Wesley's marriage.
And about why Priscilla had been so desperate to secure control before Arthur saw the blue folder.
Related Stories
