Chapter 18 - WHY RUTH HID THE LETTERSRuth’s confession became more detailed in therapy.
At first she said fear.
Then jealousy.
Then shame.
Finally anger.
“I was angry at Catherine before knowing her.”
“Why?”
“Because she had right to want you.”
“And I had right to love you.”
“I thought only one could win.”
Lacey looked.
“Who taught?”
“No one.”
“Adoption culture then.”
“People told us we were your real parents.”
“They meant reassurance.”
“It made biology threat.”
Ruth remembered agency saying:
“Birth family gone. Clean legal slate.”
Clean.
Again.
Daniel challenged.
Ruth embraced.
Because infertility grief.
She had lost three pregnancies.
Two adoption disruptions.
Lacey’s placement felt salvation.
If original family appeared, Ruth feared universe taking again.
Understanding.
Still not excuse.
At age fourteen, second Harold letter explicitly named Alder.
Daniel wanted consult independent investigator.
Ruth refused.
They fought.
Daniel slept couch.
Eventually he agreed delay.
This damaged marriage silently.
Lacey never knew.
At eighteen, Daniel prepared reveal.
Ruth said:
“Let her start college without chaos.”
At twenty-one:
“She is stressed.”
At twenty-three:
“After graduation.”
Then Daniel died.
Ruth became only keeper.
She told herself dying husband would want peace.
But his letter proved opposite.
Lacey said:
“You used him after death.”
Ruth cried.
“Yes.”
Hard.
Therapy not cozy.
Lacey sometimes left furious.
But truth deepened.
She also confronted own desire to punish by withdrawal.
Maya:
“Space can be boundary.”
“It can also be weapon.”
“Know difference.”
Lacey considered.
She did not owe Ruth comfort.
But if she wanted relationship, indefinite silence perhaps not.
She set:
one call weekly.
No adoption talk unless scheduled.
Normal relationship too.
They discussed garden.
Neighbor.
Tessa.
This helped Ruth not reduce herself to guilty adoptive mother.
Catherine similarly had boundaries:
one lunch every two weeks.
No surprise gifts over $100 without asking.
No employment intervention.
No “my daughter” publicly.
No Lucy.
Catherine agreed.
Once she broke gift boundary:
Sent Lacey expensive coat after hearing cold commute.
Lacey returned.
Catherine embarrassed.
“I thought practical.”
“It’s $1,800.”
“I didn’t know—”
She did know.
Lacey stared.
Catherine laughed.
“Okay, I knew.”
“Ask.”
“Yes.”
Humor.
Power with wealth required explicit.
Later Catherine asked:
“Can I pay therapy?”
“No.”
“Can trust?”
“No.”
“Okay.”
Lacey eventually accepted Jonathan trust distributions; then therapy paid by her money. Clean.
Ruth learned Catherine relationship exists.
Jealousy.
She admitted.
Lacey said:
“You can feel.”
“Don’t make me fix.”
Ruth:
“I won’t.”
May you like
This became mature.
The more both mothers tolerated discomfort, the less Lacey needed choose.
Related Stories
