Chapter 9 - THE LIE AT THE FARMHOUSEBy sunrise, the Mitchell farmhouse was no longer only a home.
It was a crime scene.
Officers photographed the broken telephone cord, the overturned kitchen chair and muddy footprints leading toward the stable.
One set belonged to Sarah’s worn boots.
Four smaller sets belonged to the children.
Robert’s deeper prints followed behind them.
The exterior bolt carried fresh fingerprints.
An investigator lifted several clear impressions from the metal.
Robert’s were among them.
Lucas returned to the stable.
In daylight, details hidden by darkness became visible.
A fresh scrape marked the interior doorframe where Sarah had forced the hook into place.
The exterior bolt could not fall by itself. It had to be lifted, slid horizontally and dropped into a metal bracket.
Robert’s explanation was physically impossible.
Near the lantern, Lucas found a shallow space beneath a loose floorboard.
It was empty.
Only a rectangle in the dust suggested something had been hidden there.
At the county jail, Robert sat across from his attorney, Mark Ellison.
The attorney placed copies of the preliminary police report on the table.
“You told officers the bolt fell.”
“It could have.”
“The investigators tested it.”
Robert’s eyes narrowed.
“Then Sarah lowered it before she went inside.”
“From the outside?”
“She could have asked Emma to do it.”
“Your daughter called the police.”
“She’s been manipulated.”
Mark studied him.
“You need to understand the position you’re in. The interrupted emergency call, the injuries and the children’s statements are serious.”
“My wife is trying to steal my property.”
“The bank may take your property before she can.”
Robert’s face hardened.
Mark had discovered the foreclosure notices.
He also knew about the life insurance application.
“Did you sign Sarah’s name?”
“No.”
“Did she?”
Robert leaned back.
“She forgets things.”
Mark closed the file.
“Do not build your defense around attacking your wife’s mental health unless you have records supporting it.”
“I have more than records.”
“What does that mean?”
Robert did not answer.
At the hospital, Sarah gave permission for Lucas to show her the red notebook.
Most pages contained her handwriting.
Dates.
Amounts Robert drank.
Threats he made.
Money that disappeared.
On the final written page, Sarah had described her plan to leave on Friday night with the girls.
That was the current night.
Below her last sentence, someone else had written four words in black ink.
You will never leave.
Sarah’s hand flew to her mouth.
“That’s his writing.”
Lucas photographed the page.
“Why did you believe the notebook was destroyed?”
“He found me writing in it three months ago. He threw it into the fireplace.”
“Did you see it burn?”
“No. Mia started crying. I ran upstairs.”
Robert must have removed it from the flames.
He kept it to monitor what Sarah knew.
The realization made every room in the farmhouse feel contaminated.
Lucas turned to another page.
“Do you recognize this entry?”
Sarah read it.
Robert says if anyone comes to the house, I must tell them I am sick. He says people believe calm men before frightened women.
Sarah closed her eyes.
Emma stood beside her.
“Are they going to believe him?”
“No,” Lucas said. “Not if we keep finding the truth.”
His phone rang.
He listened without interrupting.
Then he looked at Sarah.
Robert’s bail hearing had been scheduled for that afternoon.
The prosecutor would request that he remain in custody.
But before the call ended, Lucas learned something else.
At six that morning, Robert’s attorney had filed an emergency petition accusing Sarah of kidnapping the girls, suffering paranoid episodes and attempting to flee Tennessee.
Attached to the petition was a letter signed by a doctor.
May you like
The letter claimed Sarah was mentally unstable.
The doctor named in it had been dead for two years.
Related Stories
