Chapter 4 - THE WRONG DONORThe original donor profile for D-417 arrived by secure portal the next morning.
Nadia printed it.
Not because paper was necessary.
Because she needed to hold evidence in her hands.
Donor D-417 had been thirty-two at donation.
Brown hair.
Hazel eyes.
Six feet tall.
Graduate degree in environmental engineering.
No known hereditary cardiac disease.
No psychiatric hospitalizations.
Maternal grandmother breast cancer at seventy-two.
Anonymous photo not included.
The file had been one reason Nadia chose him.
She remembered reading the essay.
Why donate?
The donor wrote:
My sister needed fertility treatment. Watching her made me understand how much biology and family can diverge. If I can help someone become a parent, that seems worth doing.
Nadia had cried.
Wesley chose him too.
Now Elena’s investigator confirmed D-417 had not fathered June.
A living donor, now fifty, consented through legal intermediary to DNA comparison after clinic notified him of potential sample irregularities.
June had no biological relation to D-417.
Clear.
The donor was horrified.
“He wants his identity kept from media.”
“Of course.”
Nadia felt strange grief for a man she never met.
They had chosen him.
Consent had been specific.
The violation was not that Kline’s genetics were inherently bad.
It was that choice was stolen.
Nadia kept reminding Wesley.
He sometimes slipped into bloodline language:
“What if Kline passed something?”
“What if all these siblings…”
Nadia corrected:
“The wrong is substitution.”
“Not whose genes are worthy.”
Priscilla, meanwhile, disappeared behind lawyers.
She hired Graham Pritchard, longtime Fairmont family counsel.
He sent message:
Mrs. Fairmont would not discuss historical reproductive matters without counsel present.
Nadia laughed when Elena forwarded.
“She thinks this is negotiation.”
“It will be legal negotiation partly.”
“I want truth.”
“Truth often comes through discovery.”
Slow.
Annoying.
Real.
Wesley agreed to clinical DNA.
June’s testing required thoughtful consent planning.
A genetic counselor, Dr. Aisha Bennett, met Nadia and Wesley.
She emphasized:
“June is five.”
“She does not need adult details now.”
“You can obtain medically relevant relationship testing while protecting future disclosure.”
“Her legal parentage is not altered by genetics.”
Wesley looked relieved.
Aisha asked:
“What do you call donor conception with June?”
Nadia:
“We told her some families need helpers to make babies.”
“She knows a donor helped.”
Wesley stared.
“You told her?”
“We told together when she was three.”
He had forgotten how natural.
Aisha nodded:
“Good.”
“If later confirmed another donor, age-appropriate truth can evolve.”
“Do not make it shame.”
Priscilla would hate that.
Truth without shame.
Clinical testing showed:
June and Wesley shared 24.7% of autosomal DNA with pattern consistent with half-sibling relationship.
Kline had not yet submitted sample.
But Wesley’s existing lab-verified parentage to Kline? They needed clinical confirmation too.
Wesley agreed.
Kline, through attorney, refused voluntary DNA initially.
Then clinic records and other descendants made inference.
But legal process later compelled? For civil suit, court order maybe.
For now, Nadia had strong.
She told Wesley:
“We need separate houses for a little while.”
His face fell.
“Because June?”
“Because us.”
He nodded.
She and June moved temporarily into Nadia’s sister Marisol Grant’s townhouse in Wayne? Could be close. Nadia's sister maybe half? Let's use sister Elise Warren, 36, lives nearby. Need new unique names maybe fine. We'll choose Elise Warren.
Nadia explained to June:
“Mom and Dad are working on grown-up problem.”
“Daddy still sees you.”
“You did nothing.”
June accepted with questions.
“Are you divorcing?”
Five-year-old heard word somewhere.
“We don’t know.”
“But we both love you.”
Wesley maintained routine.
Pickup.
Bedtime at temporary.
No conflict in front.
Priscilla was not allowed unsupervised contact temporarily because Nadia did not trust her to discuss.
Wesley resisted at first.
Then agreed.
His loyalty shifting.
The wrong donor investigation widened.
Clinic audit found a handwritten notation on Nadia’s cycle:
PF family protocol — approved SK.
PF.
Priscilla Fairmont?
Or patient file?
Maribel did not know.
The notation appeared on only three charts.
All affluent longtime Kline connections.
But their donor outcomes? One was Kline child, one not, one unknown.
Could suggest special handling.
Elena requested metadata.
The entry made by Kline’s login at 11:42 p.m. the evening before insemination.
Nadia stared.
“Was he physically there?”
Badge logs:
Yes.
He entered cryostorage lab after hours.
Embryologist on duty, Derek Sloan, signed inventory next morning.
Derek retired.
Now living Delaware.
Elena said:
“Do not contact personally.”
“Investigator through counsel.”
Derek agreed interview.
He remembered Kline micromanaging “VIP patients.”
“He’d come in after hours.”
“Say he was verifying samples.”
“Did he substitute?”
“I never saw.”
“Did Priscilla visit?”
Derek paused.
“A blonde older woman came through private entrance once.”
“Could be.”
“Not during procedure?”
“Same week.”
Security archive images no longer? Some backups discovered? Too old 6 years perhaps retained due clinic compliance. Visitor log:
P. Fairmont — Dr. Kline personal guest — 7:30 p.m.
Three days before insemination.
Wesley stared at record.
“She told us she was in Palm Beach.”
Nadia looked.
There was lie.
What did Priscilla and Kline discuss?
Pritchard claimed private medical matter.
Nadia laughed.
“Her medical matter?”
Maybe.
Elena:
“Could be.”
“Don’t assume.”
Facts.
Then billing record:
A payment of $75,000 from Fairmont Family Holdings to a consulting entity owned by Kline, two weeks before June’s conception.
Memo:
Genetic continuity consultation.
Nadia went still.
Wesley read twice.
“What does that mean?”
Elena:
“We ask.”
Fairmont Family Holdings was controlled by Priscilla as trustee of certain family assets.
Payment not through clinic.
Direct to Kline’s private consulting company.
Priscilla had paid him seventy-five thousand dollars immediately before June’s donor cycle for something called genetic continuity.
Wesley sat.
His face went blank.
Nadia watched him process that his mother might have turned his daughter’s conception into a private bloodline project.
He whispered:
“She always said Fairmont name had to continue.”
Nadia said:
“Name can continue without genes.”
“She didn’t believe.”
“What exactly did she say growing up?”
Wesley looked away.
“Blood remembers.”
“Names can be stolen.”
“Blood can’t.”
Nadia felt sick.
Priscilla, who had secretly raised a donor-conceived son not biologically descended from Charles Fairmont, became obsessed with blood.
Contradiction?
Or compensation.
Perhaps once she learned Wesley was Kline’s child, she feared family line broken.
Using Kline again for June would make June genetically connected to Wesley through same biological father.
Not Fairmont blood.
But Wesley’s bloodline.
A twisted attempt to create genetic kinship where donor conception otherwise would not.
Nadia whispered:
“She wanted June related to you.”
Wesley’s face crumpled.
“So she used my biological father.”
Nadia nodded slowly.
“If that is what happened.”
He looked nauseated.
“She made my daughter my sister.”
“Genetically.”
“Stop qualifying.”
“I need qualify.”
He stood and paced.
Nadia let.
Then he said:
“I want to confront.”
Elena shook head.
“Not yet.”
Wesley turned.
“That’s my mother.”
“And potential defendant.”
“I don’t care.”
“You should.”
“Because you want truth admissible, not destroyed.”
Nadia almost smiled despite horror.
Lawyers.
Wesley sat.
“For thirty-eight years everyone decided what I was allowed to know.”
Nadia looked at him.
“And five years you did same to me.”
He closed eyes.
“Yes.”
“That ends.”
“Yes.”
No excuses.
Good.
That evening, June FaceTimed.
“Daddy, look.”
She held missing tooth? At 5 maybe first loose tooth. She showed glitter drawing.
Wesley smiled.
After call he cried alone.
Nadia did not comfort.
Not cruelty.
Boundary.
He had to hold his own grief.
Hours later, Elena called.
“We received archive from Kline’s private consulting server.”
Nadia’s pulse jumped.
“There is a document titled Fairmont Continuity Plan.”
Wesley looked up.
“What does it say?”
Elena paused.
“I think you both need read yourselves.”
May you like
And for the first time, the mystery stopped looking like random fertility fraud.
Someone had written down a plan.
Related Stories
